The most prominent Islamic scholar in Gaza has issued a rare, powerful fatwa condemning Hamas’s 7 October 2023 attack on Israel, which triggered the devastating war in the Palestinian territory.
Professor Dr Salman al-Dayah, a former dean of the Faculty of Sharia and Law at the Hamas-affiliated Islamic University of Gaza, is one of the region’s most respected religious authorities, so his legal opinion carries significant weight among Gaza’s two million population, which is predominantly Sunni Muslim.
A fatwa is a non-binding Islamic legal ruling from a respected religious scholar usually based on the Quran or the Sunnah – the sayings and practices of the Prophet Muhammad.
Dr Dayah’s fatwa, which was published in a detailed six-page document, criticises Hamas for what he calls “violating Islamic principles governing jihad”.
Jihad means “struggle” in Arabic and in Islam it can be a personal struggle for spiritual improvement or a military struggle against unbelievers.
Dr Dayah adds: “If the pillars, causes, or conditions of jihad are not met, it must be avoided in order to avoid destroying people’s lives. This is something that is easy to guess for our country’s politicians, so the attack must have been avoided.”
For Hamas, the fatwa represents an embarrassing and potentially damaging critique, particularly as the group often justifies its attacks on Israel through religious arguments to garner support from Arab and Muslim communities.
The 7 October attack saw hundreds of Hamas gunmen from Gaza invade southern Israel. About 1,200 people were killed and 251 others taken hostage.
Israel responded by launching a military campaign to destroy Hamas, during which more than 43,400 people have been killed in Gaza, according to the Hamas-run health ministry.
- Israel Gaza war: History of the conflict explained
- What is Hamas and why is it fighting with Israel in Gaza?
Dr Dayah argues that the significant civilian casualties in Gaza, together with the widespread destruction of civilian infrastructure and humanitarian disaster that have followed the 7 October attack, means that it was in direct contradiction to the teachings of Islam.
Hamas, he says, has failed in its obligations of “keeping fighters away from the homes of defenceless [Palestinian] civilians and their shelters, and providing security and safety as much as possible in the various aspects of life… security, economic, health, and education, and saving enough supplies for them.”
Dr Dayah points to Quranic verses and the Sunnah that set strict conditions for the conduct of jihad, including the necessity of avoiding actions that provoke an excessive and disproportionate response by an opponent.
His fatwa highlights that, according to Islamic law, a military raid should not trigger a response that exceeds the intended benefits of the action.
He also stresses that Muslim leaders are obligated to ensure the safety and well-being of non-combatants, including by providing food, medicine, and refuge to those not involved in the fighting.
“Human life is more precious to God than Mecca,” Dr Dayah states.
His opposition to the 7 October attack is especially significant given his deep influence in Gaza, where he is seen as a key religious figure and a vocal critic of Islamist movements, including Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad.
His moderate Salafist beliefs place him in direct opposition to Hamas’s approach to armed resistance and its ties to Shia-ruled Iran.
Salafists are fundamentalists who seek to adhere the example of the Prophet Muhammad and the first generations who followed him.
Dr Dayah has consistently argued for the establishment of an Islamic caliphate that adheres strictly to Islamic law, rather than the political party-based systems that Hamas and other groups advocate.
“Our role model is the Prophet Muhammad, who founded a nation and did not establish political parties that divide the nation. Therefore, parties in Islam are forbidden,” he said in a sermon he gave at a mosque several years ago.
He has also condemned extremism, opposing jihadist groups like Islamic State and al-Qaeda, and has used all of his platforms to issue fatwas on various social and political issues, ranging from commercial transactions, social disputes over marriage and divorce, to the conduct of political violence.
Advertisement
The fatwa adds to the growing internal debate within Gaza and the broader Arab world over the moral and legal imimplications of Hamas’s actions, and it is likely to fuel further divisions within Palestinian society regarding the use of armed resistance in the ongoing conflict with Israel.
Sheikh Ashraf Ahmed, one of Dr Dayah’s students who was forced to leave his house in Gaza City last year and flee to the south of Gaza with his wife and nine children, told the BBC: “Our scholar [Dr Dayah] refused to leave his home in northern Gaza despite the fears of Israeli air strikes. He chose to fulfil his religious duty by issuing his legal opinion on the attack”.
Ahmed described the fatwa as the most powerful legal judgment of a historical moment. “It’s a deeply well researched document, reflecting Dayah’s commitment to Islamic jurisprudence,” he said.
Hello there! Do yoou usse Twitter? I’d like to follow yoou if thaat wouyld bee okay.
I’m undoubtedly enjoyibg your blpog annd look forward too nnew updates.
I like the valuablpe info you provide in yopur articles. I’ll bookmark yur
bllg and check again here regularly. I’m qite certain I wll larn a
lott oof new stuff right here! Goood luck for thhe next!
Right now it appears liuke Expression Engin is the
topp blogging platform available rigjt now. (from what I’ve read) Is
that whgat yyou are usingg onn ypur blog?
Thhank yyou for the auspicious writeup. It in fact waas a amusemejt acount it.
Look advanced too ffar added agreeable frdom you!
By thee way, howw cann we communicate?
I was wondering iff youu ever thougut oof changing thhe layouit of ykur site?
Itss ery well written; I llve what youuve ggot tto say.
But maybe you couild a littlpe moree in tthe waay of contednt soo peopoe could connecht
with itt better. Youve got an awfu lot oof tsxt forr only
aving 1 orr twwo pictures. Maybe yyou could spacee itt out better?
Heolo There. I discovered your weblog thee usagge oof msn. Thaat is ann extremely
welol written article. I will maake sure to bookmark
it andd return to learn estra of yyour useful info.
Thhanks forr the post. I will certainly return.
It’s vsry trouble-free to find out any mtter onn webb as compared to textbooks, ass I found thios ppost aat this site.
This is a topic that’s close tto mmy heart… Bestt
wishes! Exactly where aare your ontact details though?
Hmmm iis anyopne eelse aving problems wjth thhe pictures
onn this blog loading? I’m trying to figure out iif itts a prolem on my eend or iff it’s tthe blog.
Any redsponses would bbe greatly appreciated.
Thanks foor sharing yourr thoughts. I reaally appreciage youjr efforts and I willl
bee wqiting foor yoour further write upps thannk yoou onxe again.
Helloo too all, thee contents exissting aat this web sikte are really awesomje forr pesople knowledge, well, keep uup
thhe good work fellows.
I’m amazed, I musat say. Rarel do I encounter a bllog that’s blth equally
educatve andd amusing, and wuthout a doubt, you’ve hiit the nasil
on tthe head. Thhe issuee is something nnot enoughh people aree speaking
intelliigently about. Noww i’m veery happy I stumbled
acrpss this in myy seazrch foor solmething concerning this.
Yesterday, while I was aat work, my cousi stoe mmy iphone aand testerd to seee iif itt can survvive a 25 foot drop, just soo she caan bee
a ykutube sensation. My apple pad is noww destroyed annd she
has 83 views. I know this is totall offf topc butt I had to share
it with someone!
Let me share the harsh truth: most HVAC failures happen because someone ignored a step. Did not calculate the load accurately. Used incorrect equipment. Miscalculated the insulation needs. We’ve fixed hundreds of these messes. And each time, we remember another lesson. Like in 2017, when we decided on adding smart thermostats to every system. Why? Because Sarah, our senior tech, got frustrated of watching homeowners waste money on bad temperature control. Now clients save hundreds yearly.
https://www.linkedin.com/company/product-air-heating-cooling-and-electrical
https://bravomos.ru/ bravomos
удивительный Факты, интересные факты, события на Дзен: поиск правды. Достоверность – краеугольный камень любого контента. Феномен Дзен, существование, явления – это не просто слова, это процессы, требующие осмысления. Выводы, тайны, результаты на Дзен: анализируя настоящее. Действительность, истина, реальность – где они? Явь, явления – всё взаимосвязано. Информация, сообщения, происшествия, инциденты, случаи, исключения – всё это формирует картину мира. Сумасшествие, ужасы, кошмары, жуть, удивление, безнадёжность, страх – спектр эмоций, который дарит Дзен. Беззаконие и беспорядок: анархия как отражение проблем общества.
бездепозитные фриспины Бездепозитные Промокоды: Секретный Ключ к Эксклюзивным Бонусам Бездепозитные промокоды – это специальные коды, которые можно активировать в казино, чтобы получить эксклюзивный бездепозитный бонус.
бездепозитные бонусы казино Казино с бездепозитным бонусом – это идеальный вариант для тех, кто хочет попробовать свои силы в азартных играх, не рискуя собственными деньгами. Однако, перед тем, как воспользоваться таким предложением, внимательно изучите правила и условия его получения и отыгрыша.
https://github.com/logonx/Windows-App/releases
установка электрического карниза Электрический карниз: Симфония комфорта и технологичности в вашем доме. Откройте для себя мир, где управление светом становится легким и интуитивно понятным, а шторы – не просто элемент декора, а часть интеллектуальной системы вашего жилища.
https://enran.ua/
Your point of view caught my eye and was very interesting. Thanks. I have a question for you. https://accounts.binance.info/ar-BH/register?ref=S5H7X3LP
Your article helped me a lot, is there any more related content? Thanks!